Prophecy
Sennacherib will fall by the sword in his own land (Isaiah 37:7)
○ Written after the events, according to historians; tradition dates it before
Written 701 BC according to tradition; 681–540 BC according to historians. Event: 681–680 BC.
See the full entry: sources, objections, answersIn short
The announcement. The prophet Isaiah, in the book of Isaiah, in 701 BC according to the account, announces that Sennacherib, king of Assyria, will return to his own land and fall there by the sword.
What happened. Twenty years later, in 681/680 BC, a Babylonian chronicle reports that Sennacherib is killed by his son during a revolt. Another of his sons, Esarhaddon, succeeds him, as the Bible also says.
What is still debated. the announcement and its fulfillment appear in the same account, which some scholars consider written after 681 BC, when the murder was already known.
What would be striking if the text came first
A tablet written by the Babylonians confirms the murder by his son, and the Bible knows accurate details: the successor, the murderers’ flight to Ararat. But announcement and fulfillment are in the same account, which historians date to after the murder.
Main objection (in French for now)
L’annonce (Es 37:7) et son accomplissement (Es 37:38) appartiennent au même récit, que N. Na’aman juge rédigé au plus tôt après 681 : l’auteur connaissait le meurtre au moment d’écrire la prédiction.
The text (World English Bible)
Behold, I will put a spirit in him and he will hear news, and will return to his own land. I will cause him to fall by the sword in his own land.”’”
Isa 37:7
Sources
- ABC 1, colonne iii (Chronique de Nabû-nasir à Šamaš-šuma-ukin) — Livius.org, d’après A. K. Grayson
- A Failed Coup: The Assassination of Sennacherib and the Assyrian Civil War of 681 BC (Christopher Jones) — The Ancient Near East Today 13.5, American Society of Overseas Research
- New Light on Hezekiah’s Second Prophetic Story (2 Kgs 19,9b-35) (Nadav Na’aman) — Biblica 81 (2000), p. 393-402, Institut biblique pontifical
- Hezekiah (Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11e éd., 1911) — Wikisource, texte de l’Encyclopaedia Britannica de 1911
- Dating ancient manuscripts using radiocarbon and AI-based writing style analysis (Popović et al.) — PLOS ONE 20(6), DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0323185
- Commentaires classiques sur Ésaïe 37:7 (Keil-Delitzsch, Pulpit Commentary) — Bible Hub (commentaires du domaine public)
- Commentaires classiques sur 2 Rois 19:37 (Ellicott) — Bible Hub (commentaires du domaine public)
- Talmud de Babylone, Sanhédrin 96a (William Davidson Edition) — Sefaria